Implications for energy security and affordability

Straitened circumstances

  • Recent crises underline the need for secure, affordable energy. This presents policy makers with a multifaceted challenge, and possible ways forward reveal synergies but also difficult trade-offs, making comprehensive approaches critical.

  • Improving fuel security requires diversity of suppliers and routes, adequate storage and spare capacity, and investment in legacy assets and new infrastructure, with needs varying markedly by scenario. Fuel-importing regions cut oil and gas imports by around 15% to 2035 in the Additional Response Case (ARC), mainly through efficiency and electrification, while imports remain broadly flat in the Stated Policies Scenario (STEPS).

  • In terms of electricity security, electrification can reduce exposure to traded fuels but brings new risks. Peak demand for electricity grows by 40-50% by 2035 across scenarios, while shares of solar photovoltaics and wind rise rapidly. System adequacy therefore requires new capacity and robust grids, while flexibility requires more storage, demand response and diverse generation mixes.

  • Critical minerals have moved to the forefront of energy and national security. Both mining and refining are heavily concentrated, with the top supplying country holding 85% of refined magnet rare earth and around 75% of refined lithium and cobalt supply. There are also some gaps between existing and planned supply and projected demand, including a 25% deficit for copper by 2035 in the STEPS.

  • Building greater systemic resilience is essential, with energy infrastructure increasingly at risk from severe weather and malicious attacks. Each year, an average of 190 million customers are reported to experience power outages linked to natural hazards, and exposure is set to worsen as temperatures rise. Proven measures can mitigate these risks but often require additional investment.

  • The lack of energy access is the most fundamental form of energy insecurity. Around 720 million people still lack access to electricity, and 2 billion lack access to clean cooking technologies. Universal access requires more investment to expand grids, mini-grids and renewables, and to fund the equipment and infrastructure necessary to make liquefied petroleum gas and other clean cooking options widely available.

  • Concerns about affordability have intensified after recent fossil fuel price spikes. For importers, energy system costs are lower in scenarios that see faster energy transitions, but this requires large upfront investments in more efficient technologies.

  • Policy decisions will have impacts on emissions. In several net-importing countries, the most effective way to improve energy security is to boost investment in clean energy technologies, which accelerates emissions reductions; in others, coal-fired generation capacity remains a key part of electricity security.

The pillars of energy security

Energy systems can draw on a range of attributes or principles to protect against vulnerabilities and hazards. 

Adequacy Flexibility Resilience Diversity Robustness Seconds Hours Days Months Years Decades Adequacy Flexibility Resilience Diversity Robustness Seconds Hours Days Months Years Decades

Global short-term flexibility needs grow strongly in all scenarios

The rise of variable sources like solar PV, and electrification of demand, drive growing needs for short-term balancing in electricity systems.

x1 2025 x2.2 CPS 2035 x2.4 STEPS 2035 x3.6 NZE 2035 x1 2025 x2.2 CPS 2035 x2.4 STEPS 2035 x3.6 NZE 2035

Imports through the Strait of Hormuz, 2025

Each dot represents 0.1 mb/d of crude oil imports. Red dots pass through Hormuz. The percentages indicate the share of imports via Hormuz.

European Union Crude oil 6% LNG 8% China Crude oil 44% LNG 31% Japan and Korea Crude oil 63% LNG 11% India Crude oil 41% LNG 60% Southeast Asia Crude oil 66% LNG 21% Other Asia Crude oil 65% LNG 60% European Union Crude oil 6% LNG 8% China Crude oil 44% LNG 31% Japan and Korea Crude oil 63% LNG 11% India Crude oil 41% LNG 60% Southeast Asia Crude oil 66% LNG 21% Other Asia Crude oil 65% LNG 60%

Critical mineral markets are relatively small, but they enable huge amounts of economic activity

The annual market for magnet rare earths is less than USD 10 billion, but their supply disruption could result in USD 6.5 trillion economic impact per year.

Rare earths USD <10 bn Automotive USD 3.3 tn Aviation, trucks and trains 1.1 tn Electronics 1.0 tn Defence 0.6 tn Data centres 0.4 tn Other 0.2 tn Rare earths USD <10 bn Automotive USD 3.3 tn Aviation, trucks and trains 1.1 tn Electronics 1.0 tn Defence 0.6 tn Data centres 0.4 tn Other 0.2 tn