Rail
Why is it important?
Urban and high-speed rail infrastructures have scaled up rapidly over the past decade, laying the foundation for convenient, low-emissions transport within and between cities. Rail emissions per passenger kilometre are currently on average around one-fifth those of air travel. Emissions from electrified passenger rail are even lower, particularly when powered by renewables or nuclear power.
What is rail's role in clean energy transitions?
The low energy and CO2 intensities of rail transport make promoting rail a promising strategy to diversify energy sources and reduce emissions. However, like all other transport infrastructure, rail investment is expensive. High levels of infrastruture utilisation are necessary for rail construction projects to pay off, both economically and environmentally.
Where do we need to go?
Although rail is already the most electrified transport subsector, now all new tracks on high-throughput corridors will have to be electric to achieve the Net Zero pathway. On rail lines where throughput is too low to make electrification economically viable, hydrogen or battery electric trains coupled with partial track electrification and well-located charging points will need to replace diesel trains.
Tracking Rail
From their peak in 2019, direct CO2 emissions from rail remain under 100 Mt CO2. During the past two decades, direct CO2 emissions from diesel rail operations increased by 0.6% on average annually. To get on track with the Net Zero Emissions by 2050 (NZE) Scenario, emissions will need to decline by about 5% annually to 2030, a goal which requires the electrification of diesel operations wherever viable, as well as the use of biodiesel blends and implementation of a wide range of other efficiency measures.
Europe targets modernisation of the rail network and India rapid electrification, while China is expanding its network with a focus on high-speed rail
Europe targets modernisation of the rail network and India rapid electrification, while China is expanding its network with a focus on high-speed rail
Countries and regions making notable progress in this sector include:
- China's railway network reached 155 000 km by the end of 2022, of which 42 000 km are high-speed railways.1 The largest high-speed rail system in the world has grown 100 times in the past 20 years and is expected to further expand to 50 000 km by 2025, improving access to mobility, enabling modal shift and reducing oil demand.
- Japan's Hitachi and Italy's Trenitalia together introduced the FrecciaRossa 1000 high-speed train in Italy in 2015, and it is now also operating in France and Spain, expanding the European railway market and improving rail competitiveness. In 2022 the partnership presented a new high-speed hybrid train that can switch between battery, electric or diesel and can function in both electrified and non-electrified lines, further modernising the European rolling stock.
- India is investing in road-to-rail shift and is rapidly moving towards its target of 100% rail track electrification by 2024, with the share of electrified track increasing from 45% in 2015 to 80% in 2022.
- Ethiopia-Djibouti's 753 km rail line, powered by hydro-generated electricity, started operating in 2016 and is the first modern electrified railway in East Africa, bringing economic growth and taking tonne-kilometres off the road.
1Considering high-speed train’s commercial speed of 200 km/h and above. For IEA modelling purposes, a high-speed train is considered to have a commercial speed of 250 km/h and above.
Rail is the least emissions-intensive mode of passenger transport – its expansion will help reduce overall emissions
Rail is the least emissions-intensive mode of passenger transport – its expansion will help reduce overall emissions
CO2 emissions from rail in the Net Zero Scenario, 2010-2030
OpenElectric rail, which accounts for over 85% of passenger rail activity and 55% of freight movements, does not emit any direct CO2 emissions. Urban rail networks such as metro and light rail tend to have significantly lower emissions than other motorised urban transport modes, especially private cars, as they are powered by electricity, have lower friction losses, and exploit high occupancy rates. On a well-to-wheels basis, rail emissions per passenger kilometre average around one-fifth of those of air travel. Emissions from electrified passenger rail are even lower when powered by renewables or nuclear power. In general, rail transports around 7% of global passenger-km and 6% of tonne-km but accounts for only around 1% of transport emissions.
Expanding rail networks and their use will be important for achieving emission reductions to get on track with the NZE Scenario. European players are planning important investments in rail transport to make it more appealing to travellers, especially as an alternative to short-haul flights.
Well-to-wheel GHG intensity of motorised passenger transport modes, 2022
OpenExpansion of electric trains continues rapidly in the NZE Scenario, particularly to replace diesel-powered freight trains
Expansion of electric trains continues rapidly in the NZE Scenario, particularly to replace diesel-powered freight trains
Energy consumption for rail by fuel in the Net Zero Scenario, 2010-2030
OpenThe overall final energy mix of rail is currently split between diesel and electricity, with diesel consumption being 53% of total final energy demand compared to 45% of electricity share in 2022 (and biodiesel accounting for the remaining 1%). By 2030 in the NZE Scenario, electricity makes up 60% of total energy demand, with diesel still accounting for over a third, and biodiesel for most of the remaining share, with very minimal penetration of hydrogen.
Diesel, in particular, plays a much more prominent role in freight rail, accounting for 75% of its total energy consumption worldwide in 2022. Continuous progress on freight electrification sees this share dropping to around 55% by 2030 in the NZE Scenario.
Rail is also being more frequently explored as a solution that can provide synergies across the transport and energy sectors, which can bring numerous benefits, especially in developing economies:
- energy access – bringing clean energy access to wider geographies through rail network projects
- energy security - using rail infrastructure to regulate electricity demand and manage energy storage
- sustainability – using electric rail as a baseload demand guarantee to support the business case for renewable energy investments. Additionally, if the area is particularly suitable for clean energy generation, this can make the case for electrification of the rail infrastructure bringing green financing to the transport sector.
More than one-third of the world’s operating metro networks began running between 2017 and 2021
More than one-third of the world’s operating metro networks began running between 2017 and 2021
The world’s operating metro systems cover more than 21 000 km. Over one-third of these were put into operation between 2017 and 2021, and 80% of these new metro lines were built in Chinese cities. The picture for light rail, which has lower capacities and speeds, is similar, if less stark: over 10% of operating lines were put in place in the same five years, with just under half of them in China. The resulting efficiency of urban mobility in China results in far lower per-capita transport emissions than in cities of the developed world that are not served by metro, and can help China realise its net zero CO2 emission commitments.
Expansion of high-speed rail networks is the best way to reduce flying over short and medium distances
More than 20 countries have developed high-speed rail networks, totalling almost 60 000 km of line. China already has about 70% of the world’s line length and has long-term plans to operate nearly 65 000 km. Morocco has had great success with high-speed rail, opening the first high-speed rail system in Africa in 2018, and – in 2022 – starting to power its high-speed trains with renewable energy. Under the NZE Scenario, activity levels in high-speed rail need to increase by 75% in 2030.
Night rail services offer additional traffic at a lower marginal cost, making infrastructure investments more profitable. Renewed interest has led to an expansion of night rail connections, demonstrating that this form of travel is gaining appeal and becoming a valid competitor with aviation for short- and medium-distance trips. Europe has seen the opening of several new night lines over the past couple of years, including overnight trains between Paris and Vienna, Amsterdam and Zurich, and Brussels and Prague, each with a number of intermediate stops. Night trains have continued to be an established practice after the Covid-19 pandemic in Eastern Europe, Asia and to a lesser degree in North America.
Hydrogen projects are on the rise, further cementing this fuel as a key pillar in the broader energy transition
Hydrogen projects are on the rise, further cementing this fuel as a key pillar in the broader energy transition
Demonstration projects in the Netherlands, Canada and Japan aim to test the viability of hydrogen as an alternative to diesel rail lines with low utilisation and as a low-carbon fuel for rail in certain operations, including for conventional (intercity) passenger rail and for freight rail.
Proponents of fuel cell trains point to their potential to run over long ranges (up to 1 000 km at a maximum speed of 140 km/h) without refuelling, noting that fuel cell trains do not require spending on catenary lines, making them more competitive with the electrification option when it comes to long-distance low-utilisation routes. They also highlight the potential for quick refuelling times.
In 2022, Germany started operating 14 hydrogen trains to serve passenger transit over a 100 km track in the state of Lower Saxony, part of a larger order from train manufacturer Alstom totalling 41 trains. In 2023, France ordered 12 hydrogen trains that will soon start test-runs, while the Italian Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport assigned EUR 300 million for the purchase of hydrogen-powered rolling stock and the production, storage and supply of renewable hydrogen.
Hydrogen projects have often been clustered in advanced economies, which have more financial resources at their disposal to invest in innovative technologies. This past year has seen some emerging and developing economies also investing in hydrogen rail projects, notably India’s 89 km long Sonipat-Jind route, where test-runs are expected to start in December 2023.
In March 2022, the Japanese JR East has started test runs of the hydrogen-hybrid train HYBARI, which is powered by hydrogen fuel cells and batteries. It is the first heavy train to use high-pressure hydrogen (70 MPa) which increases maximum distance capacity. Spain's CAF, on the other hand, has started dynamic track testing of its own hydrogen fuel cell and battery-powered hybrid train. In Chile, the mining railway Ferrocarril de Antofagasta a Bolivia will introduce hydrogen trains in 2024.
Clean Tech Guide: Transport, Rail, Biofuels, Refining, Hydrogen. Cross-cutting themes: Direct electrification.
For more information
Hyperloop, battery train, magnetic levitation rail and rail-to-grid management technologies are emerging, offering new transport decarbonisation and optimisation solutions
Following the EU announcement of financial support for the commercialisation of the hyperloop technology, pioneering companies launched the "Hyperloop Association" in December 2022, and a hyperloop testing facility is being set up in Groningen.
The EU is also funding the development of Railway to Grid management systems via the E-LOBSTER project. The platform could provide a real-time energy flow management between rail, the electricity grid, energy storage and electric vehicle charging station systems, utilising the train's regenerative braking and reducing the grid's distribution losses. A testing tool has been successfully implemented in Madrid, and the innovation was demonstrated and validated at the University of Newcastle.
Stadler, Utah State University and ASPIRE Engineering Research Center are developing a fully battery electric train, the FLIRT Akku, and have already sold over 110 units and replaced diesel fleets in some places in Germany. The co-operation aims to redesign this train to meet market requirements in the United States.
China's first domestic magnetic levitation (maglev) line began testing in March 2023. The line will be 38 km long with a first phase of 8 km to open in late 2023.
Regional policies focus on rail modernisation, expansion, digitalisation and low-carbon technologies
Regional policies focus on rail modernisation, expansion, digitalisation and low-carbon technologies
A range of recent policies allocate public funding to extend railway infrastructure, modernise fleets and upgrade digital operations (including software and equipment).
Country/region |
Policy (year announced) |
---|---|
Argentina |
Passenger Rail Transport Modernisation Plan: Extension of and improvement in regional services, modernisation and technology upgrades (2021). |
Austria |
Modal switching: State-owned railway company ÖBB to build and expand European long-distance night train connections by 2026 to improve alternatives to air routes (2021). |
Canada |
Public funding to support major public transport system planning and development (including rail), as well as establishing a permanent public transit fund of CAD 3 billion (USD 2.2 billion) per year, beginning in 2026-2027 (2021). |
China |
Major State Council guidance to ministries and the State Assets Commission to promote the “green transformation” of society and the economy, including a strategy to develop major transport projects and increase national railway development capital by CNY 100 billion (USD 14 billion) (2020). |
Egypt |
The high-speed rail mega project, with an estimated cost of USD 23 billion, is a 2 000 km long railway network. In January 2021 Egypt's National Authority for Tunnels signed a contract with Siemens to begin the construction of the first 460 km. This part of the project is expected to conclude in 2024 (2021). |
European Union |
Recovery and resilience plans to support modernisation, an increase in rail infrastructure capacity and its digitalisation, the decarbonisation of railways through electrification or alternative energy sources, and investment in high-speed rail in multiple member states (Croatia, Czechia, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia and Sweden). Connecting Europe Facility to fund key projects in the areas of transport, digitalisation and energy from 2021 to 2027. This includes supporting the development and modernisation of rail across member states, with priority given to the Trans-European Network (TEN-T). |
India |
Green Railway by 2030 Plan: Aim to replace railway system with “green railways”, including electrification, improving the energy efficiency of trains and fixed installations, acquiring green certification for stations/installations and switching to renewable sources of energy. Aim to electrify all broad gauge networks by December 2023 (2020). Aim to increase rail transportation from 36% to 45% by 2030, thus reducing transportation by less efficient diesel road vehicles (2021). |
Norway |
National Transport Plan: to strengthen railway services by building new rail infrastructure and better rail network coverage, digitalisation and modernisation (2021). |
Saudi Arabia |
USD 22.5 billion Riyadh metro project will be one of the largest public transport network projects in the world: 6 automated lines at a total length of 176 km and 85 metro stations will cover key city areas, with 60 km of the route underground (2023). |
Spain |
Innovation Strategy in High-Speed Trains: green loan to finance R&D on light high-speed trains and to develop new rolling stock solutions and produce portfolio expansion (2022). |
United States |
Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act: investment in modernisation and upgrades of passenger and freight rail (2021). |
View all transport policies
We would like to thank the following external reviewers:
We would like to thank the following external reviewers:
- Lucie Anderton, Joo Hyun Ha, Alice Favre and Philippe Stefanos, International Union of Railways
- Jacopo Tattini, European Commission
Recommendations
-
Clear policies and targets to achieve "avoid", "shift" and "improve" measures can accelerate the decarbonisation of mobility. Making rail more viable is not only a matter of investing in trains and tracks, but also requires measures to tame traffic. Fiscal measures such as congestion charges and emission taxes, applied primarily to roadways and aviation, and based on the use of the transport network and externalities, can directly increase the competitiveness of rail. Additionally, low-carbon fuel blending mandates in road and aviation sectors also make rail transportation more economically attractive. For instance, removing fossil fuel subsidies and internalising the environmental and social externalities of aviation through a tax levied on aviation fuels would help level the playing field and make high-speed rail more cost-competitive for long-distance travel.
Meanwhile, some share of the revenues generated from fuel taxes, parking fees, road pricing and tolls can be invested in rail infrastructure and can encourage modal shift by reducing the appeal of private vehicle use. Similarly, proceeds from transport taxation (e.g. vehicle purchase and registration taxes) could be allocated to rail improvements and extensions.
Discounted passenger train tickets, such as the EUR 49 per month "Deutschland ticket", introduced in 2023 to alleviate the pressure of inflation and promote the use of public transportation, the "KlimaTicket" in Austria, free train travel on selected routes in France, Spain, Luxembourg and Estonia could incentivise modal shift, especially if accompanied with investment in good connectivity and customer experience.
-
Conventional rail companies will need to upgrade their rolling stock and further electrify services, starting with the most heavily used routes. Introducing energy efficiency measures would both reduce environmental impacts and improve economic viability.
The adoption of digital technologies could optimise rail operations and integrate rail more comprehensively with other mobility services, making rail more accessible, convenient and attractive. Digital tools are therefore important for improving operational and energy efficiency, cutting costs and increasing revenues.
Integrating renewable energy production facilities on or near to railway systems, as already done in Switzerland and India, can reduce rail reliability on the grid and make clean energy projects economically viable. Train station and depot rooftops, as well as track-side land, can be used to house facilities to generate electricity for stations or power trains directly.
-
Rail development financing does not need to rely solely on public funding. Capturing land value benefits can also offset high capital investment costs. For instance, network developers can capitalise on increased land values by undertaking high-profit commercial and residential projects near railway nodes and stations. In addition, financial and regulatory systems should encourage railway companies to access sustainable financing sources such as green bonds.
Policies that promote high-density living and incorporate transport into urban development planning can help achieve high passenger throughput on urban rail networks. Adopting an integrated approach to transport can minimise commuting times. Furthermore, land use planning should accommodate city logistics by incorporating ideally located multi-modal hubs. These should link rail to cargo, cycling infrastructure and zero-emission fleets. Transit-oriented development can connect urban rail with bus networks as well as pedestrian and cycle paths.
-
Investing in rail infrastructure is expensive. For a rail construction project to pay off, high passenger or freight throughput is necessary. The adoption of digital technologies could optimise rail operations and integrate rail more comprehensively with other mobility services, making rail more accessible, flexible, convenient and attractive.
The Future of Rail
Global demand for transport is growing fast. Given present trends, passenger and freight activity will more than double by 2050.
Authors and contributors
Lead authors
Oskaras Alšauskas
Contributors
Jacob Teter
Natalia Triunfo